Sometimes things just happen for a reason. You are in that place at that time (I am hesitant to call it the right place at the right time…not sure why). You walk into a situation and you have the opportunity to offer another way that was not available. That doesn’t necessarily mean that you should offer another way, but the stars have aligned…and there it is…the opportunity.
What do you do? What do I do? Today’s musing is me giving voice to a conversation that has been rattling in my head since Christmas Eve. I am at a crossroads and I am genuinely unsure of what to do next.
It would be unfair to babble using vague examples, so I will set the stage. I have been an Episcopalian for my entire life (for those of you who need reference for that you can go here – http://www.episcopalchurch.org/posts/publicaffairs/episcopal-church-core-beliefs-and-doctrines to find out all about what we believe). I have been a member of Grace Church Baldwinsville for most of my life. My wife has been received in our church, both of my daughters are baptized Episcopalians, and when we go to church, we go to Grace. We have tried other churches but Grace is home.
When I was very young (somewhere between 2nd and 4th grade), I began singing in the choir. My Grace Church Choir experience (and Phyllis Spisak) is probably the single greatest factor in my decision to become a chorus teacher. The adults who nurtured me through the years are an integral part of my development into an adult. Over the years, I have sang in the Grace Church choir and watched as people come and go, but the core group of 4-10 stays the same. That core group has kept that choir going for 30+ years. Many of them are now 60+ years old. Through 3 or 4 organist/choir directors they have kept the faith and I have nothing but the utmost respect for their dedication.
Mainstream churches are showing a decline in population across the globe. The membership is getting older and is not being replaced with as much “young blood.” As a result, their financial strength is also weakened and it becomes harder and harder to pay for everything.
Grace Church recently found itself in need of a new organist/choir director (the previous one took a job closer to home, I believe). I was on the leadership council (Vestry) when this person was hired and I remember how difficult it was to find a candidate then (that was many years ago). Organists are expensive (and rightly so) and choir directors are as well. When you need someone who can do both…it complicates the search even more. On top of that, music schools are not putting out as many organ majors as they once were (20 years ago when I was in college….I believe we had 3…..total). This creates a problem, how does a Church with a shrinking membership (pledge base) afford the rising cost of an organist/choir director for a program that has fought so hard to stay an integral part of the church life?
I should mention that these are only my observations. I have not spoken with the leadership at Grace and perhaps they have no problem, but they have been without a music director for a little while now, so I am concerned…on a very personal level.
Christmas Eve was the first time I had been to church since May. There is no good reason other that I prioritized other things ahead of Grace (and I regret that choice). When we arrived at church, I found out the previous music director had left and that there were no candidates on on the horizon (according to one long time member of the church). The choir on Christmas Eve was no more than 10 voices. The next week I went, there were even fewer. I went this morning and there were 2.
This saddens me. I know that a program with0ut a leader has a tough time finding its way. And during the difficult transition time, you can lose people just because of the sense of flux. This choir is my single greatest memory of my foundational years. I hurt watching this program suffer.
I am not an organist…not even close. I play piano effectively, but more than 3 pedals confuses me. I am in no position to fill the organists role…at least not on a permanent basis. I can sub, but they need someone with far more training than I have.
I am however, a choir director…and a music director. I have 2 decades of experience in running a music department. I have worked with instrumentalists and vocalists alike. I can program concerts and develop strong ensembles. I have worked with struggling choirs and helped them rebuild.
Here is where my conundrum lies. I have a possible solution to the issue at hand. Unfortunately, it will require the Church to make some changes to long-held traditions (and that is hard for any group). I am not certain that they will ameliorate the challenges, but I believe that they will. However, to apply this solution (assuming the Church is interested in trying my suggestion…I would completely understand if they didn’t) would require me to give more of my family time. I have been working over the past year to increase my time at home and this would require me to be away from home an additional night a week. At the same time, at my core, I feel compelled to help the people that have given me so much over the course of my life.
I am a giver. I want so much to be able to give to everyone. I am also of limited financial means. I cannot even afford to tithe appropriately. What I have is time…and I am always drawn to give it, because it is all that I have.
I have talked with my wife about it and I know that she will support me no matter what I decided to do in the end.
I am at a precipice moment. I have the opportunity to offer a possible solution. I have weighed the options and tried to consider the consequences. But even after writing all of this (and proofreading it) I am still unsure of which path to take. Did I happen upon this by chance? Or was I meant to be here at this moment? I am sure that the Church will soldier on if I do nothing, but at the same time my heart is drawn to help…
I am sure that a solution will make itself apparent.
Thank you for listening!
Have a GREAT day!